Lumber dried to moisture contents of 6-8 percent, thus suitable for the manufacturer of products used indoors, develops stress. It is said to be ``casehardened.'' Drying stresses are a normal result of the drying process. They can develop in the air drying yard, in the predryer, during dehumidification drying, or particularly during steam kiln drying. Drying stresses may be either transverse or longitudinal, the transverse type generally creating the most problems.
The severity of the drying stresses varies with the drying method and the drying conditions. As the lumber is machined, the stresses are relieved, and unacceptable distortion often results (Figure 1). Thus, these stresses should be relieved during the drying operation for lumber which is cut up and used in manufacturing products.
To understand stress or casehardening, the manner in which a board dries needs to be considered. During drying, the surface loses moisture first, moisture from inside the board migrates outward, and it, too, evaporates. A moisture gradient going from a high moisture content in the core to a low moisture content on the surface or shell develops.
As a board continues to dry, the surface eventually tries to shrink. In the early stages, it is restrained by the core, which is fully swollen. The shell is stressed in tension, and surface checks (cracks) may develop. The core is in compression. As drying continues, the core begins to shrink and pulls the shell into compression. Surface checks may close. The core is now in tension. The transverse stresses which have developed are more or less uniform across the thickness, width, and length of the piece. The lumber appears normal, but it is not. The stress needs to be relieved.
Warping is probably one of the most noticeable defects which can result from casehardened lumber (Figure 2). During the resawing of thick stock into thinner material, stresses in the boards are unbalanced, and cup or bow with the concave edge toward the saw will result. The curvature or distortion develops because the core of the board is normally in tension, and it is pulling the surface or shell inward. Ripsawing may relieve longitudinal stress. When the board is ripped, crook may develop with the concave edges towards the saw. This obviously results in manufacturing problems or discarding of the material.
End checking can occur in the core of freshly crosscut casehardened boards. One case has been reported where excessive end splits developed in panels immediately after high frequency gluing.1 The splits were all in the wood and not the glue line. The problem was thought, at first, to be due to high moisture content in the wood, but an oven-dry test showed it all to be about 6 percent. The kiln operator had been relieving transverse stress. However, longitudinal stress was still present, as indicated by the test described later. Special kiln sets were made to relieve the longitudinal stress, and the problem ended.
During planing, if the cut is not uniform on both sides, the board will cup, with the concave face being the one most heavily machined. The lips on edge grooved material may turn inward and break as the tongue or spline is inserted. In producing moulding and trim or during routing and carving, where unequal cuts are necessary, cupping will likely result.
Planer splits can occur in relatively flat lumber which is casehardened. The splits result from the internal drying stresses and the action of the knives.
Boring will also be difficult in casehardened lumber. The bit is being pinched by the board.
Squares can also be casehardened. If casehardening exists, splits along the length and end splits may develop even though the moisture content is at 6-8 percent.
Tests for Drying Stresses Drying stresses and moisture content can be checked on lumber. Figure 3 shows an example of how to cut the specimens. The moisture content and transverse stress specimens are about one inch in width along the grain and full width of the piece. First the average moisture content section is weighed as soon as it is cut from the board. The scales should have a precision of 0.5 percent of the weight of the section and read in grams. The moisture content section is then oven-dried at 101o -105o C to a constant or oven-dry weight. To determine if the weight is constant, simply keep weighing the specimen every couple of hours until it stops losing weight. The moisture content is then calculated by the following formula.
original weight - oven dry weight
--------------------------------- x 100
oven dry weight
This gives the average percent moisture content of the sample based on oven-dry weight, and it should fall within the range specified, or 6-8 percent for hardwoods which are to be used for interior products.
Next, the moisture content of the shell and core are calculated. The thickness of the shell portion of the sample is about 1/4 the total thickness of the moisture distribution section. The shell part and the core section should be weighed immediately upon cutting. They are then oven-dried, and the moisture content calculated as before. A uniform moisture content throughout the piece is ideal. If the moisture content is not uniform, the stress test could be misleading.
The stress section is used to determine the presence of casehardening in the board. The core of the section is simply removed with a band saw. If the two outer prongs pinch in, the section is casehardened or has residual drying stress. The prongs turn in because the tension stress in the core is released by the saw cut, and the inner faces of the prong shorten because of the release of the stress. Figure 4 shows sections with different degrees of stress and for different thicknesses of lumber. If the stress is severe, the prongs will snap together. In this case, the stress section can be turned down and band sawed in such a way as to allow diagonally opposite prongs to bypass each other.
Residual drying stresses and moisture gradients sometimes interact and can cause confusion. If the core of a stress section is not at the same equilibrium moisture content as the air where it is cut, the moisture content of the core will change, and the inner face will shrink or swell. Most commonly, the core is at a high enough moisture content that it shrinks when cut, the prongs move in, and it appears to be casehardened.
The time required for prong movement is a good indication of whether residual drying stresses or moisture gradients or a combination of these two cause prong movement. Residual drying stresses cause prong movement immediately, whereas a change caused by moisture content requires at least several hours to complete. If immediate prong movement is observed, followed by additional prong movement, then both factors are the cause. In either case, prong movement points to a condition that should be corrected to avoid warp upon resawing or machining. Either additional stress relief or equalization or both procedures are required. Reverse casehardening (Figure 4) occurs when the lumber is over conditioned when relieving drying stresses. It is a stress condition that cannot be corrected.
Longitudinal stresses can also develop in a board and should be monitored for the reasons discussed earlier. A method to prepare longitudinal stress or tension set sticks is shown in Figure 3. Each stick should be 1 inch wide and at least 12 inches along the grain and the full thickness of the board. Saw kerfs shown as thin void areas in Figure 3 should be placed along the length and parallel to the original surface (face) of the board. If both of the outer prongs bow inward and pinch the saw, the sample probably has longitudinal drying stress. If only one outer prong pinches the saw, the sample probably has growth stresses from reaction wood.
To check for longitudinal stress in squares, 1/8-inch-thick sections were cut along the grain.1 These sections were then broken along the grain. The pieces were fitted back together. When the pieces fit perfectly, no defects developed in the turning operation. When stress was present, a small crack indicating casehardening could be seen between the pieces, and splits occurred on the turned stock.
To test for growth stresses or reaction wood, cut a sample similar to the tension test. However, in this case, place the saw kerfs perpendicular to the board surface. If the prongs bow in, the sample has longitudinal stress due to reaction wood. Reaction wood can result for growth stresses which occur naturally, or tension wood which is generally present in the upper part of leaning trees. Neither is the result of poor drying practices, and neither is considered a grading defect in hardwood lumber. Their presence is generally too sporadic to facilitate separation, and excessive degrade generally does not result.
Figure 1. Unacceptable distortation from a poorly dried sample of 8/4 red oak is shown. The outer surface of this piece was in the 6-8 percent moisture content range, but the interior was much higher. In addition, the specimen had not been stress relieved. When the prong test was con- ducted, the outer prongs turned in from stress and from interior drying. The inner prongs shortened becaus_e of interior tension and from shrinkage due to additional drying.
Figure 2. This stile from a cabinet door was split into four quadrants with a bandsaw. The lower right quadrant turned out and the upper right turned in. The two quadrants on the left pinched together and closed the saw cut. The lumber was case hardened and resulted in excessive warp in the cabinet door.
Figure 3. Method of cutting sections for final moisture content and drying stress tests. MC is moisture content. (Courtesy of the U.S. Forest Products Laboratory)
Figure 4. Visual degree of casehardening and method of cutting stress sections for casehardening tests. Lumber that is less than 1-1/2 inch thick is cut into three prongs, and the middle prong is removed; lumber that is 1-1/2 inch thick or thicker is cut into six prongs, and the second and fifth prongs are removed. (Courtesy of the U.S. Forest Products Laboratory)
Cooperative Extension Work in Agriculture and Home Economics, State of Indiana, Purdue University and U.S. Department of Agriculture Cooperating. H.A. Wadsworth, Director, West Lafayette, IN. Issued in furtherance of the Acts of May 8 and June 30, 1914. It is the policy of the Cooperative Extension Service of Purdue University that all persons shall have equal opportunity and access to our programs and facilities.